Examine a Ship: Spock and Bones
Jan. 21st, 2015 11:56 pmAlright, I started out with Korra and Asami. Then I moved to Katara and Zuko. I've stayed well within my own straight, male gaze and it's about time that I step outside.
Let's look at Science Officer/First Officer Spock and ship's chief medical officer Leonard "Bones" McCoy.
Beyond simply stepping outside my own gaze for the sake, there's the reality that the original series had a lack of well-realized women in their character roster.
There was one nurse who had an infatuation with Spock. Can you state another character trait of hers? Professional, perhaps, based on an episode in which the Enterprise had almost found her husband. There was Ohura who, only in the original series mind you, seemed often like little more than a token woman on board and nothing else.
I want to be clear that I'm not taking issue with the acting. It was well done on both parts. I am taking issue with the writing that did not give fully fleshed out characters where there was a great deal of potential.
That said, the reason I don't pair Kirk with either is that being forced to watch Kirk seduce various women (for the good of the galaxy, of course) would put a strain on any relationship. Kirk has a close friendship with both Spock and McCoy, but I don't see any reason it has to be more than that.
Spock and McCoy share one of the most entertaining dynamics of the franchise. They trade barbs with a visible glee, or as close as can be displayed for Spock. They never actually take insult from each other. And, episodes like Amok Time show that they nigh-instinctively refrain when matters are sensitive.
This dynamic displays playfulness, respect, and an inherent trust in each to understand the other's boundaries. Almost by accident, I just described the foundation of a healthy romantic relationship.
The Spock/McCoy dynamic indicates a long-time established couple, one that has moved past the initial honeymoon stage, has weathered disagreements, and has come out the other end stronger for it. They're like an old married couple that works together and saves worlds together. Here's hoping that they enjoyed their retirement years before Bones passed on and Spock took on the goal of peace between Vulcan and Romulus.
Let's look at Science Officer/First Officer Spock and ship's chief medical officer Leonard "Bones" McCoy.
Beyond simply stepping outside my own gaze for the sake, there's the reality that the original series had a lack of well-realized women in their character roster.
There was one nurse who had an infatuation with Spock. Can you state another character trait of hers? Professional, perhaps, based on an episode in which the Enterprise had almost found her husband. There was Ohura who, only in the original series mind you, seemed often like little more than a token woman on board and nothing else.
I want to be clear that I'm not taking issue with the acting. It was well done on both parts. I am taking issue with the writing that did not give fully fleshed out characters where there was a great deal of potential.
That said, the reason I don't pair Kirk with either is that being forced to watch Kirk seduce various women (for the good of the galaxy, of course) would put a strain on any relationship. Kirk has a close friendship with both Spock and McCoy, but I don't see any reason it has to be more than that.
Spock and McCoy share one of the most entertaining dynamics of the franchise. They trade barbs with a visible glee, or as close as can be displayed for Spock. They never actually take insult from each other. And, episodes like Amok Time show that they nigh-instinctively refrain when matters are sensitive.
This dynamic displays playfulness, respect, and an inherent trust in each to understand the other's boundaries. Almost by accident, I just described the foundation of a healthy romantic relationship.
The Spock/McCoy dynamic indicates a long-time established couple, one that has moved past the initial honeymoon stage, has weathered disagreements, and has come out the other end stronger for it. They're like an old married couple that works together and saves worlds together. Here's hoping that they enjoyed their retirement years before Bones passed on and Spock took on the goal of peace between Vulcan and Romulus.